The Newport City Council voted 5-1 Wednesday to authorize a letter of intent to purchase 101 Malbone Road for a price not to exceed $6 million, over the objection of a councilor who questioned how the city arrived at the figure.
The property is intended for a public safety complex. The authorizing item also cites preserving municipal control of the site and advancing the goals of the North End Urban Plan.
Fire Chief Humphrey “Harp” Donnelly IV said the owner had set a price of $7 million and that the $6 million figure was reached over roughly two years of what he called “pretty challenging negotiations.” He said the current owner bought the property in 2020 for $3.6 million, after it had been listed at $5 million.
Carlin asked Deputy City Manager Michael Caruolo whether the administration knew the property had been shown on the private market within the last 18 months at an asking price of $4 million, and whether anyone in city government was aware of it. Caruolo called Donnelly forward, saying the fire chief “has been intimately involved in these conversations with the current property owner.”
Donnelly, who also serves as the city’s director of emergency management, said he was not. “I know that we haven’t had exclusivity when we’re looking at that property or negotiations,” he said. “So I’m not aware of other showings or other asking prices.” He said he was familiar only with the last two years of negotiations, and that the history was “something to talk about over a cup of coffee.”
Caruolo said Donnelly and Police Chief Ryan Duffy had spent nearly three years searching for a site that could accommodate a public safety complex or other municipal use. He said the administration would examine Carlin’s claim, and that if the negotiations were found not to have been conducted in good faith, “it would certainly be cause for the city to abandon this agreement.”
Carlin said his information came from what he had been told and acknowledged he could be wrong. “I wonder out loud why the seller would show the property with an asking price of 4 million and then negotiate with the city for potentially 6,000,000,” he said.
Mayor Charles Holder objected to the framing. “Unless we have absolute proof that that’s the case, to argue this on hearsay, I don’t think is appropriate at this time,” he said. Holder argued the city should control land in the North End rather than leave it to a private developer, and pointed to past opportunities the city did not take. He also noted the letter contemplates the city selling another municipal property, which he said could reduce the net cost.
City Solicitor Christopher Behan told the council a letter of intent does not commit the city to buy. Its purpose, he said, is to take the property off the market while the parties work toward a purchase and sale agreement. He cautioned, however, that the letter sets material terms the seller will expect to hold.
Holder asked Caruolo to confirm the funding source. Caruolo said the 2024 infrastructure bond included $13 million for the project, including acquisition, and was approved by nearly 71% of voters.
Vice Chair Lynn Underwood Ceglie said the council had discussed the property in at least two executive sessions and that the price was not a surprise. “If we pass up this opportunity, we pass up an opportunity for a lifetime,” she said, noting the site already has utilities, unlike other parcels the city has pursued.
Councilor Xay Khamsyvoravong voted in favor while urging further review. “I do believe the city can want to proceed forward aggressively with acquiring any parcel of property in that North End area,” he said, “but also be doing additional due diligence to ensure that what we’re paying for that property is actually fair in accordance with the market.” He said the two positions “aren’t necessarily adverse.”
Carlin voted no and said the decision should have waited for the incoming council, which takes office in early December. “Knowing that the new council is going to be inaugurated within just a few days, it’s somewhat disrespectful to put a potential $6 million contract in front of us,” he said. He and Khamsyvoravong both asked the incoming council to review the matter.
Councilor Ellen Pinnock was absent.
